No Child Left Behind & the Battle in Wisconsin

No Child Left Behind & the Battle in Wisconsin

I have two images in mind whenever I think about our former president, George “Dubya” Bush; either the scared ‘deer in the headlights’ look like, ‘uh oh, I’m in deep trouble now,’ or the smug rooster strutting around the world stage proclaiming ‘I’m the decider’or ‘I’m the war president!’ And with the latest assault on our rights, our livelihoods, & our dignity as evidenced in Madison, Wisconsin, I made another connection as to why the bushwhacker, Cheney, & Rove are so pleased with themselves.

It was pointed-out by several commentators on the Left that the governor of Wisconsin’s attack on collective bargaining is more an assault on teachers than anything else. Reflecting on this idea a bit more, it dawned on me that this was a very significant insight into the strategy of the reactionary right or fascists, to be more exact. By the way, I’m not using the term ‘fascist,’ loosely or just to be provocative, I use it here because I accept the definition of fascism that Mussolini is said to have meant it i.e. fascism should more rightly be called corporatism because it is a marriage of government and business.

To return to the subject of the far right’s war against public education, the reader of this essay may dismiss the following as “conspiracy theory,” but if you’ll do a little research you’ll discover that this isn’t conspiratorial but rather, “common sense” amongst the elite in the U.S. and has been for decades. I don’t want to wander too far off the subject so I’ll just paraphrase a quote from former U.S. president, Woodrow Wilson; “There are two types of education, one for the elite, destined to govern America and, the other type for the workers who only need to know enough to operate the machines in the factories.” I learned this from John Taylor Gatto’s excellent work The Underground History of American Education.
In view of the recent “prank” phone call made by the Left-wing blogger to Wisconsin’s governor during the massive protests in Madison, where he posed as David Koch, the billionaire, who along with his brother are funding many of the attacks on democrats and social policies/programs around the country, I believe it’s pretty obvious as to what these fascists’ game plan for America is. Remember, only one person in that phone conversation was “pretending,” and it wasn’t the blogger. They, the power elite, have taken the gloves off i.e. they’re not subtly pulling the strings from behind the curtains any longer. No, they’ve come out of the closest and are waging full-scale, frontal attacks in their desire to wipe-out every last vestige of democracy, equality, justice, & fairness in America.

For example, are you aware of the fact that the Koch brothers entertained Supreme Court Justices Scalia & Thomas, just before the infamous ruling of the Supreme Court in the Citizens United case? Gee, just a pleasant little get together? Yeah, right! These greedy pigs are hell bent on privatizing everything on the planet so just a relative handful of powerful families will literally rule the planet. By eliminating public employees from being able to collectively bargain, in one fell swoop they are emasculating public unions and therefore seriously reducing their ability to contribute financially to democratic campaigns while they can donate (bribe) as many politicians as they want. And I’m not defending democrats because in general, they too have sold their souls to the highest bidders. I am defending our right to band together and bargain from a position of some power in the never ending battles with corporate C.E.O.s who persistently try to turn back the clock and take back fair wages, safety in the workplace, pensions, etc.

You may be wondering what all this has to do with the No Child Left Behind law that the “war president,” whose daddy covered for his desertion from the Texas Air National Guard, passed. Okay, because of the seriousness and the national scope of this “law” i.e. No Child Left Behind, I am going to include the entire transcript from the Sixty Minutes expose from several years ago:
he ‘Texas Miracle’
60 Minutes II Investigates Claims That Houston Schools Falsified Dropout Rates
• Font size
• Print
• E-mail
• Share
By Rebecca Leung
Like this Story? Share it:
Share On Facebook

Robert Kimball, former assistant principal at Houston’s Sharpstown High School, found that his school’s low dropout rates were just too good to be true. (CBS)
• Former Houston School Superintendent Rod Paige was given credit for the school success. (CBS)
• Interactive Education In America
Backpack ready? Learn more about education in America through fun facts, national statistics and unusual schools.
(CBS) It was called the “Texas Miracle,” a phrase you may remember because President Bush wanted everyone to know about it during his 2000 presidential campaign.

It was an approach to education that was showing amazing results, particularly in Houston, where dropout rates plunged and test scores soared.

Houston School Superintendent Rod Paige was given credit for the schools’ success, by making principals and administrators accountable for how well their students did.

Once he was elected president, Mr. Bush named Paige as secretary of education. And Houston became the model for the president’s “No Child Left Behind” education reform act.

Now, as Correspondent Dan Rather reported last winter, it turns out that some of those miraculous claims which Houston made were wrong.

And it all came to light when one assistant principal took a close look at his school’s phenomenally low dropout rates – and found that they were just too good to be true.
“I was shocked. I said, ‘How can that be,’” says Robert Kimball, an assistant principal at Sharpstown High School, on Houston’s West Side. His school claimed that no students – not a single one – had dropped out in 2001-2002.

But that’s not what Kimball saw: “I had been at the high school for three years, and I had seen many, many students, several hundred a year, go out the door. And I knew that they were quitting. They told me they were quitting.”

Most of the 1,700 students at Sharpstown High are under-privileged immigrants — prime candidates for dropping out.

One student was Jennys Franco Gomez. She dropped out of Sharpstown in 2001 for an all-too-familiar reason: she had a baby. “My baby got sick, and I don’t have nobody to take care of my baby and take it to the doctor,” she says.

The high school reported that Gomez left to get a GED, or equivalency diploma, which doesn’t count as a dropout. But Gomez says she never told school officials anything of the sort.

All in all, 463 kids left Sharpstown High School that year, for a variety of reasons. The school reported zero dropouts, but dozens of the students did just that. School officials hid that fact by classifying, or coding, them as leaving for acceptable reasons: transferring to another school, or returning to their native country.

“That’s how you get to zero dropouts. By assigning codes that say, ‘Well, this student, you know, went to another school. He did this or that.’ And basically, all 463 students disappeared. And the school reported zero dropouts for the year,” says Kimball. “They were not counted as dropouts, so the school had an outstanding record.”

Sharpstown High wasn’t the only “outstanding” school. The Houston school district reported a citywide dropout rate of 1.5 percent. But educators and experts 60 Minutes checked with put Houston’s true dropout rate somewhere between 25 and 50 percent.

“But the teachers didn’t believe it. They knew it was cooking the books. They told me that. Parents told me that,” says Kimball. “The superintendent of schools would make the public believe it was one school. But it is in the system, it is in all of Houston.”

Those low dropout rates – in Houston and all of Texas – were one of the accomplishments then-Texas Gov. George Bush cited when he campaigned to become the “Education President.”

At that time, Paige was running Houston’s schools, and he had instituted a policy of holding principals accountable for how their students did. Principals worked under one-year contracts, and each year, the school district set strict goals in areas like dropout rates and test scores.

Principals who met the goals got cash bonuses of up to $5,000, and other perks. Those who fell short were transferred, demoted or forced out.
Kimball took his findings about Sharpstown High to CBS affiliate KHOU-TV, which first reported the dropout scandal.

Then, he went to State Rep. Rick Noriega. In Noriega’s largely Hispanic, mostly poor district, many kids start high school, but never finish.

“In my district in particular, where I have many of my high schools, 1,000 ninth-grade students, yet only approx 300 or so will walk the stage four years later and receive a diploma. A big question should go off in people’s heads, where are the other students?” says Noriega, who asked the state to find out.

Investigators checked half of the city’s regular high schools. They reviewed the records of nearly 5,500 students who left those schools, and checked how the schools explained it. They found that almost 3,000 students should have been, but weren’t, coded as dropouts. The audit substantiated Kimball’s allegations.

“The problem is the lack of integrity that’s being demonstrated when you say there’s such a low dropout rate, when we know, everyone knows, that 30 to 40 percent of the kids are dropping out of schools,” says Kimball.

60 Minutes wanted to ask Houston school officials about Kimball’s charges, but they wouldn’t talk on camera. They said they wouldn’t “get a fair shake.” But they did meet off camera, and they argued that the audit proved outright fraud only at Sharpstown High.

At the other schools, they contended, the false statistics were due to “confusion” about the complex state system for coding students, and sloppy bookkeeping. They conceded, however, that Houston’s “official” 1.5 percent dropout rate was not accurate.

Those officials also urged 60 Minutes to get a better picture of the Houston school system on by talking on camera to Rob Mosbacher, a Houston businessman, school supporter and Republican activist.

“I think the district looks at the challenges it has, and sets high expectations. And that’s something that makes all of us very proud. Because they’ve been making the progress that shows that expectations can be realized,” says Mosbacher.

60 Minutes also tried to talk to Paige himself, but he declined. His spokesman said the dropout controversy broke after Paige left Houston to become education secretary. And he said the phony statistics at Sharpstown were the work of a few individuals.

Paige’s spokesman suggested that 60 Minutes talk to Jay Greene, a leading expert on dropouts at the Manhattan Institute. Greene supports the kind of accountability reforms Paige enacted in Houston.

But this is what Greene said when asked what he thought about Houston’s “official” dropout rates: “I find that very hard to believe. It is almost certainly not true. I think it’s simply implausible. I think a reasonable guess is that almost half of Houston’s students do not graduate from high school.”

Greene also points out that Houston’s dropout problem is no worse than that of school systems in many other large American cities: “I think they are doing about as well as most urban school districts, which is to say not very well … I don’t think they’ve been doing super well.”
Houston also won national acclaim for raising the average scores on a statewide achievement test that was given to 10th graders. Principals were judged on how well their students did on the test.

But at Houston schools, Kimball says, principals taught addition by subtraction: They raised average test scores by keeping low-performing kids from taking the test. And in some cases, that meant keeping kids from getting to the 10th grade at all.

“What the schools did, and what Sharpstown High School did, they said, ‘OK, you cannot go to the 10th grade unless you pass all these courses in the 9th grade,” says Kimball.

What’s wrong with that? Wouldn’t this help students get the basics down before moving on?

“Because you failed algebra, you may be in the ninth grade three years, until you pass the course. But that’s not a social promotion if you just allowed the student to go to 10th grade, just you know, let him take algebra again, and work on it there.”

That’s just what happened to Perla Arredondo. She passed all her courses in ninth grade, but was then told she had to repeat the same grade and the same courses.

“I went to my counselor’s office, and I told her, ‘You’re giving me the wrong classes, because I already passed ‘em,” says Perla. “So she said, ‘Don’t worry about it. I know what I’m doing. That’s my job.’”

Perla spent three years in the ninth grade. She failed algebra, but passed it in summer school. Finally, she was promoted – right past 10th grade and that important test — and into the 11th. Without enough credits to graduate, Perla dropped out. While she worked as a cashier, a secretary, and a waitress, she learned an important lesson: “I know I can’t get a good job without a high school diploma. You know? I can get a job as a waitress. I mean, and I don’t wanna be doing that all my life.”

Why? “For my dad and mom. You know, I wanna give ‘em, I want them to be proud, you know,” says Perla. “That’s another thing I want. I want them to be, you know, proud of what I am.”
Gilbert Moreno has seen many Perla Arredondos. He runs a school filled with dropouts.

“There are some horrible stories,” says Moreno, who is director of the Association for the Advancement of Mexican-Americans, which operates a private, non-profit charter high school for disadvantaged kids.

“A youngster passed, say, five different subjects, passed the English, but wasn’t given the algebra, and then was later told, at the end of the year, ‘Well, you’re not gonna pass to the 10th grade. You never passed algebra. You never took algebra,’” says Moreno. “And the youngster goes, ‘I never knew this.’ And it looks almost that there was an attempt to maybe identify some certain students and not give them the required curriculum.”

There is no state audit to back up this claim, but Moreno points out that many Houston high schools have bulging ninth grades, and very small 10th grades. One school, he says, held back more than 60 percent of its ninth-graders.

School officials say students are held back because they’re not ready for the next grade. They deny that they were held back to avoid the test.

Students and teachers at Moreno’s charter school showed 60 Minutes that dropouts are not a lost cause. Former dropouts get help here to stay in school. Classes are small, there is daycare for students with children, and programs to combat drugs and gangs.

There was determination, ambition and hope in their voices.

Roscio dreams of becoming a cartoonist. “I’m really good at drawing,” he says.

“Right now, I want to go to med school and continue to become a pediatrician,” says Victor.

And Vanessa dreams of becoming a journalist.
Noriega says Houston school officials focus on statistics instead of real problems: “That’s the issue. It’s the kids, stupid. And people continue to wanna spin around it all, and lose sight of it all. And it’s Kimball, and it’s just one school, and it’s this and it’s that. And it’s not.”

If that sounds like a political statement, it’s because questions about the Houston school miracle are now being raised in Washington.

And Education Secretary Paige, who declined to give 60 Minutes an interview, responded to those questions in a speech in Houston just before Christmas 2003: “Critics come after the school district in Houston. Not Sacramento, not Denver, Boston or Los Angeles. It is Houston that they put on the front page. They come after you, not because of an interest in quality education, but because of where you live.”

And in the case of whistle-blower Kimball, school officials have denounced him as incompetent, and transferred him to a primary school for kindergarten through second grade, where he is the second assistant principal.

“The district felt that, by sending me down there, somebody who’s taught at university level, taught at high school level, and middle school level, would be humiliated at a low primary school, but I’m telling you that I love it,” says Kimball, who adds he isn’t going to quit.
After 60 Minutes broadcast that story, Robert Kimball filed a whistle-blower suit against the Houston School District for retaliating against him.

The school board dropped its reprimand and paid Kimball $90,000. Kimball resigned and is now teaching at a local university. A few weeks later, three top school board officials, including Superintendent Kay Stripling, resigned their posts.

State Representative Rick Noriega, a major in the Army Reserves, is now on active duty in Afghanistan.
©MMIV, CBS Broadcasting Inc. All Rights Reserved.

By passing No Child Left Behind and making it the law of the land, the putrid power elite struck a crippling blow against our public education system because teachers & principals must now spend the majority of their time teaching students how to pass these “standardized” tests which takes away precious time for teaching what’s truly significant in terms of empowering students.

I have worked as an educator for over 15 years in a wide variety of capacities. I have been a substitute teacher at the secondary level, an adult education teacher, a teaching assistant in special education, etc. And I earned a B.A. in English literature and have been an avid reader for most of my life. Therefore, in my opinion, a true education i.e. one that causes people to fall in love with learning and to become lifelong learners, and enables them to become self-learners can be boiled down to critical & analytical learning as well as exposure to & serious examination, discussion, reflection on the great classics in literature, history, philosophy, politics, religion, science, mathematics, etc. As well as familiarity with many of the modern or contemporary classics. Under No Child Left Behind, students are forced to memorize dull, unconnected facts, figures, dates, and sanitized i.e. distorted views of American history, etc.

Therefore, by eliminating the right for public employees to bargain collectively, they not only prevent teachers from coming together to protest laws/policies like No Child Left Behind, they also get one step closer to becoming the permanent party in power in America. Moreover, they also help to stifle further dissent among the poor, the working class, & the disappearing middle class because our students & future voters will be even more dumbed-down than they already are. Moreover, they have already pretty much wiped-out private unions which is reflected in the fact that in the 1950s, there was something like 35% of the American workforce in private unions and it’s now down to like 7%.

In conclusion, this arrogant and illegal abuse of power by Wisconsin’s governor and several other governors around the country reveals their hidden agenda of privatizing public schools and making Charter Schools the predominant if not only avenue of education for the children of everyone who isn’t rich enough to send their kids to elite, private schools. So, by implementing a national education policy based on a lie, they can close a public school down and turn it into a private enterprise overnight and then it won’t be accountable to anyone. Do you think I’ve gone off the deep-end? How accountable is corporate America for all the fraud, environmental pollution, etc. it commits daily as a matter of course? They have privatized many of what used to be government services including many services in the military so that now we have more private military contractors in Afghanistan and Iraq than we do soldiers, who make a hell of a lot less money than the mercenaries. They’re privatizing our infrastructure (roads, bridges, airports, etc.). They tried to privatize the water supply in Bolivia (Bechtel) and the Bolivians threw them out. They’re trying to get their hands on Social Security and Medicare. I could go on for several pages just listing the things that were formerly public and are now private but note that we, the taxpayers pay for subsidizing the research and development of a lot of private industries and once they start making a profit off their new products, they keep the profit and we get nothing. The Internet is a prime example. It was engineered by the Pentagon. Globalization is simply code for the privatization of the planet. If you are concerned and would like to learn more about this sinister phenomenon, I can think of no better place to start than with Naomi Klein’s insightful book The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. In a nutshell, she substantiates from a 30 year in depth analysis of history from Pinochet’s dictatorship in Chile to the present day, how the reptilians have used natural disasters like Hurricane Katrina to man made disasters caused by the World Bank, The International Monetary Fund, the World Trade Organization, NAFTA, etc. to destroy countries’ economies and force their draconian laws on them so they could steal billions from the poor, the working, & the middle classes around the globe. So ignore me if you will but you’ve been warned and when they throw you out of your house, take every last penny of your pension plan, and tell you that you have no health insurance, perhaps my words will come back to haunt you? United we stand, divided we fall and those evil people have been dividing us for centuries so we’ll blame one another and leave them alone.

—Rob DeLoss, March 18, 2011

P.S. How accountable are the pharmaceutical corporations who sell us one fatal medicine after another? The “Defense” contractors who sell us defective tanks, helicopters, weapons, etc.? The “Energy” corporations like Exxon & B.P.? The presidents who lie us into wars? The Wall St. & Super Banks? The Food Industry who sell us harmful food approved by the F.D.A.? We’re always held accountable but they aren’t. Every now and then a corporation has to pay a small fine relative to the profits they made by committing illegal acts and now they don’t even have to admit wrongdoing in court, there’s nothing on their corporate record, and they continue to “win” government contracts. If you or I get busted for drunk driving, are we held accountable? Does our record disappear? If we write a bad check does it go on our credit record and make it hard not only for us to get more credit, rent an apartment, even get a job? Oh yeah, why do you think they’re also trying to shut down NPR & PBS? I almost forgot to explain that the governor of Wisconsin took the phone call because he believed it was David Koch because the Koch brothers have been funding the reactionary right’s assault on democracy with hundreds of millions of dollars in “campaign contributions.” And the Koch brothers are interested in Wisconsin because they know that this whore governor will sell them the public utilities companies for pennies and they can privatize them & charge the public whatever rates they want. Privatization again & again & again!

16 replies
  1. priests
    priests says:

    Hey there would you mind sharing which blog platform you’re working with? I’m going to start my own blog in the near future but I’m having a hard time selecting between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal. The reason I ask is because your layout seems different then most blogs and I’m looking for something completely unique. P.S Sorry for being off-topic but I had to ask!

    • admin
      admin says:

      I’m using Word Press and have been fumbling my way around on the Net for tips on how to do things and have had the tremendous help of a gal who has a lot more technical savvy than me.

  2. Myrtle Stritzinger
    Myrtle Stritzinger says:

    I’m not sure where you are getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for fantastic info I was looking for this information for my mission.

  3. unibet promo code
    unibet promo code says:

    I guess you have created a few rather interesting points. Not too many others would really think about it the direction you just did. I am truly impressed that there is so much about this subject that has been uncovered and you made it so nicely, with so considerably class. Superior one, man! Very wonderful things right here.

    • admin
      admin says:

      And my thanks to you. Education is a subject very close to my heart. I am still fumbling in the darkness but compliments like yours cast a little light to guide me on my way.

  4. coral bonus code
    coral bonus code says:

    Thank you, I’ve recently been searching for info about this subject for a long time and yours is the best I’ve came upon so far. But, what about the bottom line? Are you certain concerning the supply?

  5. Przewoz Osob Gdansk
    Przewoz Osob Gdansk says:

    Based on my study, after a in foreclosure home is available at a sale, it is common for your borrower to still have any remaining balance on the personal loan. There are many lenders who attempt to have all charges and liens repaid by the next buyer. Nevertheless, depending on specified programs, legislation, and state laws there may be many loans that are not easily fixed through the switch of personal loans. Therefore, the responsibility still lies on the borrower that has received his or her property in foreclosure process. Thank you for sharing your notions on this website.

  6. partybets bonus code
    partybets bonus code says:

    you are actually a just right webmaster. The site loading pace is amazing. It seems that you are doing any distinctive trick. Also, The contents are masterpiece. you have performed a great activity on this topic!


Trackbacks & Pingbacks

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Your comments Make My Day!